
For my Thinking Theologically class, I read several chapters of some books arguing for and against religion (both specific religions and religion in general). I am highly disappointed with both.
The person arguing for religion--specifically Christianity--had little to no actual rhetoric in his paper. It was just a rave against several popular books, their authors, and the two authors vs. religion whose articles we read along with the pro-Christianity one. If we as a Christian community are to become respected among our secular peers in academia, we must prove ourselves better even than those who rail against us for our faults. Remaining calm in the face of conflict is something that Jesus taught well and was a great example of. Flustered arguments (in the purely critical sense) are rarely effective and usually serve as a catalyst for more disdain, unfortunately.
The secular articles both had similar problems--not citing the sources they used for the grounding claims in the paper. But at least they were civil about it.
When writing a paper--any paper--find a reputable source for all aspects of your argument. If it is an entirely new argument (and it probably isn't brand new), base that idea in solid evidence. Or at least make logical connections to someone who has. Your audience cannot read your mind. They do not know where you get your knowledge or authority on the subject at hand--you must prove your worth to them. Example: I know this because I have taken several critical thinking and analysis classes, and a rhetoric class, in which we were shown these tactics for arguing theses. These forms were taught as far back as Aristotle.
A well-reasoned argument is a thing of great power. One that is not shows the author's weakness. I choose option number one.
